Ditch Your Old Rulebook

Almost 10 years ago, I reached a point in my career that I believe most teachers arrive to at some point. I had to acknowledge that I wasn’t as good of a teacher as I thought I was. I can recall the moment I decided that the way I was teaching wasn’t helping my students learn and I needed to change quickly.

It was time to prepare students for the state test and I was failing. My students DID NOT listen to me! None of my traditional classroom management tricks worked. As I sat at my desk feeling defeated, I thought about what the kids truly needed. I think we all can agree that test prep is grueling. It’s devoid of all joy. As my mind churned, I realized that the kids needed more joy. So I decided to find a way to link test prep with play. In order to do this, I had to ditch my old rulebook. 

What a crazy idea right? Like many teachers, I had collected a long list of dos and don’ts throughout my career. Keep your students working at all times, make sure your students understand and can repeat their learning goal for reading if an administrator asks, and most importantly, maintain control of the classroom or no one will learn anything. Here’s the thing. I realized my management was so poor that they weren’t learning anything anyway so why not trash the rulebook? Up until this point, it wasn’t helping me or my students.

My rules pointed towards structure, control and compliance. Because of this my students weren’t having fun at all. I am a fun, spontaneous person and I wasn’t even having fun while teaching because I was so focused on my long list of rules. I wanted to be the definition of the perfect teacher. I wanted to impress my principal and get her firm head nod of approval when she walked into the room. But Ms. Perfect wasn’t getting me anywhere. The truth is, Ms. Perfect was getting ignored. Each day, I followed the rules and push through the test prep packets I was given to teach. My lessons lacked excitement and joy, and I started to feel burnt out and unhappy. It wasn’t long before I noticed that my students were mirroring my own feelings.

I put the students in partners. They didn’t care. I put them in small groups. They talked over me every chance they got. Nothing I did was exciting or new so they dismissed me and my class. My classroom wasn’t a place they wanted to be and truth be told I didn’t want to be there either. I began to doubt my decision to teach at this school. I started to think that maybe I made a big mistake. And then I began to wonder, “What would happen if I just…let…go?” What if I stopped trying to force my students to learn the way my official teaching rulebook said they should? What if I actually created activities around their needs? I worried if throwing away my rulebook would change anything at all.

As I was pondering these types of questions, a lightbulb went off in my mind. Why was I so focused on myself and what others would think about me? Why did I want that head nod so bad? I shouldn’t be the primary focus of my choices; FUN should be influencing me instead! I began to imagine what the learning process would look like if I prioritized creating activities that allowed students to have as much fun as possible while collaborating with one another. I’ve always been a creative person. Why not apply my creativity to the classroom?

When I made the choice to throw away my rulebook, I made the choice to create a space that was more child-centered than I would have ever thought possible. I chose to make fun the most significant part of the experience in my classroom. When I made this choice it allowed me to escape the confines of traditional education, drop the Ms. Perfect act and create space for students to experience learning the way it was meant to be: fun!

Every time we step in front of the classroom we get to make a lasting impression on our students’ school experience. So to all my teachers out there, both fellow and future educators, have fun! Throw your rulebook in the trash and embrace your silliness! Walk on your desks (Shout out to Abbott Elementary), dress up, and most importantly, get ready to become the type of teacher your students will always remember. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *